A comprehensive comparison of these two meal kit services, including box reviews, meal plan options, sustainability, and more.
EveryPlate is a newer (launched in 2018), budget-friendly meal delivery service that provides five meal plans with the option to upgrade to premium options.
In comparison, Marley Spoon is more established with four additional years of providing meals to customers, which may cause you to wonder about the differences between Marley Spoon vs. EveryPlate.
In both cases, you’ll receive a delivery of delicious meals every week. However, many differences exist between these two meal delivery services, making it challenging to narrow down which option is best for your needs.
Below, you’ll find information on Marley Spoon and EveryPlate meals to help guide you toward the best fit.
About Martha & Marley Spoon And EveryPlate
Marley Spoon is a meal kit service that features Martha Stewart’s recipes. Each recipe requires six steps and is crafted by Martha Stewart herself. Each week, you can select between meat-based or vegetarian meals. You’ll find around 45 meal choices on the weekly menu.
EveryPlate is a meal delivery service launched under Hello Fresh to provide a more budget-friendly option to families and busy individuals. The quality of the ingredients is never sacrificed to keep the cost down. Instead, Everyplate uses significantly less packaging to help keep the price per meal low. Each week, you can select from around 25 nutritious meals.
Pros And Cons Of Both Meal Kit Delivery Services
Marley Spoon Pros
- A large number of 45 available meals weekly
- Best quality ingredients!
- Easy-to-make meals with straightforward directions
- Most meals are ready within 30 minutes
- Meal selections for different diets – low-calorie count, low-carb, vegetarian options, and more.
Marley Spoon Cons
- Additional cost per meal than Everyplate
- Shipping is not included
- One of the more budget-friendly meal kit services
- Premium choices that can be added on for an additional fee
- A smaller number of meals available, not ideal for picky eaters
- Not a good for those with other dietary restrictions
- Shipping is not included
Main Differences Martha & Marley Spoon And Everyplate
- Martha & Marley Spoon accommodates many diets, including dairy-free to gluten-free and low-calorie diets, while EveryPlate does not.
- Marley Spoon offers an impressive 45-50 recipes weekly, ensuring every customer finds options that suit their tastes versus EveryPlate’s 25 menu items.
- Marley Spoon includes breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert options, making it easier for families to craft home-cooked meals throughout the week, while EveryPlate focuses on lunch and dinner options.
Variety Of Meal Plans
Marley Spoon has many meal categories, including Health & Diet, Meat & Fish, Under 30 Minutes, Family-Friendly (kid-friendly recipes), Vegetarian & Vegan, and many more. These meal plans ensure that the majority of dietary needs are accounted for.
In comparison, EveryPlate features a straightforward selection of meal plans: Meat & Veggie, Veggie, Family Friendly, Quick & Easy, and Nutrish & Delish.
Meat & Veggie includes a tasty selection of meat-based and vegetarian-friendly meals. Veggie includes only vegetarian meals. Family-friendly ensures your kids have a great selection of meals to enjoy. Quick & Easy meals are excellent for busy families and individuals, while Nutrish & Delish options focus on nutritious meals.
Variety Of Weekly Meal Kits
As mentioned, Marley Spoon has the upper hand, with around 50 menu items each week. In contrast, EveryPlate offers 25 meal options weekly.
While EveryPlate’s options center around lunch or dinner meals, Marley Spoon also includes options for prepared meals, desserts, breakfast, appetizers, and premium upgrades.
Style And Complexity Of Meals
When comparing style, Marley Spoon has a little bit of everything, with comfort options, ethnic meal choices, and more. For example, it’s common to see meatloaf and steak au poivre as options. In contrast, EveryPlate meals are more focused on American comfort food. Expect tacos, chicken pot pies, and similar dishes for selection.
As far as complexity, they’re both about the same. Each offers easy-to-follow instructions, with all recipes having six steps.
Our Experience With The Martha & Marley Spoon And Everyplate Food Subscription Box
Both meal kit delivery services provided tasty meal options with preportioned ingredients and easy-to-follow recipe cards. We found that the recipe cards for Marley Spoon were slightly easier to follow, as they included images alongside each step. We were happy with the portions provided for each and the freshness of the ingredients.
We found that Marley Spoon was best for families or couples, whereas EveryPlate meals are excellent for individuals, couples, and families.
The meal selection is great for both, though Marley Spoon had a much wider variety of cuisine types and number of meals. Additionally, Marley Spoon has more selections for those with more specific dietary needs.
Finally, the ingredient quality was great in both. However, Marley Spoon takes it a step further by using seasonal farm-fresh ingredients and in many cases, grass-fed meat and organic produce.
Other Popular Meal Options
Martha & Marley Spoon Sample Meals We Tried
- Sirloin steak au poivre with mashed potatoes & peas
- Cod St. Jacques gratin with spinach
- Moroccan-spiced salmon & salad with green beans & tarragon dressing
- Martha’s classic one-skillet tomato pasta
EveryPlate Sample Meals We Tried
- Sweet chili chicken with scallion rice & zesty carrots
- Caramelized onion burgers with dijon aioli & potato wedges
- Linguine carbonara with peas & bacon
- Herb butter steak with roasted brussels sprouts & cheesy potatoes
Quality Of Ingredients
Marley Spoon features high-quality ingredients which are sustainably sourced. This company focuses on providing seasonal ingredients and partnering with artisan producers, ensuring every meal kit includes top-tier items that can be hard to find in a regular grocery shopping trip.
Even with a lower price point, Everyplate still includes quality ingredients in each box. They work with vendors who they have previously vetted for quality control. Each week, the suppliers change depending on the meals and the region.
Special Features And Diet Support On The Menu
As mentioned, Marley Spoon has quite a few options for dietary restrictions. You can find helpful tags under each meal option, such as dairy-free, low-carb, and more.
EveryPlate keeps it simple with vegetarian or meat-based options. When ordering, you can select a premium meal that includes high-quality ingredients. Additionally, Everyplate offers one breakfast option weekly.
Ease Of Use Of The Website & Ordering Process
Signing up for each of the meal delivery services is easy and quick. To sign up for Marley Spoon, you’ll need to select the “Sign Up” button. Then, you’ll be prompted to select your delivery plan, enter your delivery information, and input your payment details.
EveryPlate is fairly similar, but you’ll need to select the “Get Started” button before working through the funnel.
Both websites are clean and easy to navigate. Once you have signed up for your subscription, you can skip weeks, choose and change your meal selection for next deliveries, alter your account information, and more from each website.
Packaging And Sustainability
Concerning packaging, the Marley Spoon box is well-organized, saving you a few minutes when unpacking. In contrast, EveryPlate provides pre-portioned ingredients together in a box. So, you’ll need to sort through the items for each meal which can add a few minutes to the prep time.
Marley Spoon offers a detailed explanation of each part of the packaging, with most items being compostable or recyclable. Many packaging items are also made from recycled items, so they’re more sustainable.
All the components of an EveryPlate box are curbside recyclable, except for the gel ice packs and box liners. However, there are clear directions in the website’s FAQ section, which offer details on how to recycle both.
EveryPlate and Marley Spoon offer multiple options for contacting their support team should you have questions or need help with your account. Both feature a comprehensive FAQ section where you can search for commonly asked questions.
You can reach out via telephone or live chat if you need to contact Everyplate’s customer support team. You can connect with Marley Spoon’s team via phone or by submitting a ticket and your email address.
Delivery Area Availability
There is a slight difference between the delivery area for each meal kit service. EveryPlate delivers to most of the continental US, while Marley Spoon delivers to most of the contiguous US. Each meal kit allows you to type in your zip code before ordering to ensure they deliver to your area.
Our Winner Is Martha & Marley Spoon Meal Kit Delivery Service!
While we found both Everyplate and Marley Spoon meal kit services satisfactory, Martha & Marley Spoon is our winner in this comparison.
The main reason for our decision is the quality and amazing taste of the meals! Everything we tasted was, simply put, delicious.
Moreover, the number of available menu items, the very high quality of the ingredients, the easy-to-read recipe cards, and the huge variety of meals make this meal kit delivery service option a top choice.
If you’re searching for a meal kit service that offers options for many different dietary needs (including dairy-free, low-cal, low-carb, and gluten-free meals), Marley Spoon may be a good fit.