Last Updated on

We write our honest review on each company or product, however, we receive a sales commission or other compensation on the products we review. That helps us to support this website. Prices can vary due to changes in promotions or policies. See our full disclosures here.

If you are considering using a meal kit service, then you have an endless array of companies to choose from. There are now meal kit companies that cater to almost every dietary & lifestyle requirement and companies that can satisfy every budget.

When trying to decide which is the best meal kit company for you, the choices can be overwhelming. That is why we are here – to provide detailed company comparisons so you will have all the information you need, to decide on the company that is best suited to your needs.

Many people’s main concern when looking at a meal kit service is how expensive it will be. So today we are looking at two of the most affordable meal kit service companies in America. If budget is your priority and you want the cheapest meal kit services available, then this comparison between Dinnerly and EveryPlate is just for you.

Dinnerly is quite new to the industry and offers a low-price meal kit service.

Dinnerly is ideal for those who love to cook at home but who resent paying too much for their meals. The company is all about making your evening meals easier with incredibly tasty meals that only cost around $10 for dinner for two people!

EveryPlate is also focused on the bottom line by bringing you super affordable meals that cost a fraction of what most other meal kit companies cost. They use less packaging and keep things simple with fewer ingredients to bring you tasty, appealing and generous sized meals at a bargain price.

EveryPlate Unbox
Dinnerly Meal Kit Review

EveryPlate Vs Dinnerly –  Dive into a full comparison of $5 Meal Kits

EveryPlate and Dinnerly plans

Dinnerly & EveryPlate both offer two different plans that are available on a subscription basis. EveryPlate offers two main plans: 

  • A Two-person plan with the option of three to five recipes per week.
  • A Four-person plan with three recipes per week.

With Dinnerly, you can choose from:

  • A Two-person box which caters for two people with three to five recipes.
  • A Family four-person box which caters for four people with three to five recipes per week.  

With Dinnerly you also have the option with both plans to specify that your boxes be vegetarian. 

EveryPlate and Dinnerly variety and style of meals

Dinnerly offers great variety with a weekly changing menu made up of 14 tempting meal kits every week. Most of the recipes can be prepared in under 30 minutes, and on the menu, you will find some vegetarian, low-carb and child-friendly recipes, among others.

As an EveryPlate customer, you have a weekly changing menu made up of eight delicious meals. EveryPlate meal kits are generally quite classic, allowing for easy cooking without the use of too many pots, pans or complicated processes. The EveryPlate customers also have the option of upgrading and choosing a premium meal which is available for an additional $1 per person and usually includes something like steak or seafood.

Popular EveryPlate and Dinnerly dishes

Both companies offer such a wonderful selection of dishes that it is hard to choose! Here are some mouthwatering examples of the most popular meals from their weekly menus:

EveryPlate meals:

  • Sweet chili-glazed chicken with scallion rice and zesty carrots
  • Herb butter steak with roasted Brussels sprouts and cheesy potatoes
  • Crispy Ranch pork chops with roasted broccoli

Dinnerly meals:

  • No-stir shrimp scampi risotto with spinach & lemon
  • Seared chicken “Resting in Peas” with scalloped potatoes
  • Bean burrito casserole with cheddar
Steak Frites by EveryPlate
Steak Frites by EveryPlate
Roasted red peppers panini by Dinnerly
Roasted red peppers panini by Dinnerly

EveryPlate and Dinnerly quality of ingredients

When receiving the EveryPlate and Dinnerly boxes, we were impressed by the quality of the ingredients inside. Beautiful vegetables and some nice cuts of meat and chicken. The quality of ingredients is high even though the price is low. Rather than sacrificing the quality of their ingredients, it seems that they are keeping prices low by keeping things simple and being efficient in other aspects of the business!

When looking at the promises the companies make, Dinnerly states that they use only the best ingredients! They make sure to work with trustworthy suppliers, so you are always cooking with the freshest fruits and vegetables, quality proteins like grass-fed ground beef, antibiotic-free chicken, American-caught shrimp, and more. The same promise to work only with the best farms and producers is made by EveryPlate.

EveryPlate vs Dinnerly taste test

Part of our review process at The Meal Kit Review means ordering, cooking and tasting meal kits from every company we review. We are pleased to say that we enjoyed our experience with both Dinnerly and EveryPlate. We can even say we were a little surprised at how good everything tasted, given the super affordable prices they charge per serving!

With Dinnerly, the results were delicious. All the meals were easy to cook and tasted great. They were also generously portioned and very satisfying overall.

Here are some of the meals we tried out of the Dinnerly menu

Likewise, with EveryPlate, we were pleasantly surprised by our experience. It is easy to have low expectations when a meal kit service is so affordably priced, but we were really pleased with everything we tried. Every one of the meals was simple to cook and came with an easy to follow recipe card and most importantly tasted fabulous. We also loved the quality of all the ingredients that were supplied.

Here are some of the meals we tried out of the EveryPlate menu

EveryPlate review
Dinnerly Box

EveryPlate and Dinnerly nutritional value of meals

With both Dinnerly and EveryPlate, the meals are created by a professional culinary team and meals are well-balanced and nutritious, with the right proportions of carbs, proteins, and fats. The menus are focused on including fresh and cooked vegetables in almost every meal. The calorie count per serving ranges from around 500 to 900 calories and the portions are generous with meals being satisfying. Both companies offer full details regarding the nutritional values of their meals on the online menu.

The EveryPlate and Dinnerly delivery box

The Dinnerly delivery arrived in a medium-sized labeled box. The proteins were packed at the bottom of the box with enough ice to keep them cool. Part of keeping the costs down with Dinnerly is by using minimum packaging, so all the individual ingredients were not separated per meal. This required a little sorting after unpacking, but it did not take long to put everything away.

The EveryPlate delivery also arrives in a medium-sized labeled box. All the meal ingredients are packed in a smaller internal box, and the proteins are packed at the bottom of the box with enough ice to keep them cool. The box includes some recipe cards which include ingredient information and cooking instructions. To ensure their pricing is kept low, the packaging is kept to a minimum, so the meal kit ingredients are not sorted which you will need to do yourself. This only takes a moment, and it means low prices can be maintained. It is also much better for the environment. The EveryPlate box and internal separators are 100% curbside recyclable, as are the plastic bags. The gel ice packs can be recycled after emptying the gel contents into the trash, and the same goes for the liners. 

EveryPlate vs Dinnerly – special features in the menu

The menus of both EveryPlate and Dinnerly are presented in a very well organized way. Obviously, their main focus is on delivering delicious and cost-effective dinner solutions.

Each meal on the Dinnerly weekly menu is clearly marked with its special characteristics – dairy-free, no added gluten, vegetarian, low-carb, low-calorie, kid-friendly, fast under 30 minutes cooking and more.

In comparison, EveryPlate is more focused on delivering delicious foods for more common diets, and they offer a selection of meals with meat, poultry, and pork. The company offers one vegetarian meal and one premium meal every week. All of their meals are relatively easy to cook, with a cooking time ranging between 30-40 minutes.

EveryPlate and Dinnerly – flexibility

Both EveryPlate and Dinnerly offer a subscription-only service, with no option for one-off orders.  However, their subscriptions are super flexible:

  • Both companies offer the option to skip weeks when necessary and/or change your selected plan.
  • If you wish to cancel your subscription for any reason, with Both EveryPlate and Dinnerly you can easily do this online through your account management area a few days prior to the next scheduled delivery date. There are no long-term commitments here; you can subscribe for as long as you wish and cancel whenever suits.  
  • When it comes to the option of choosing your delivery date, there is also some flexibility offered by both EveryPlate and Dinnerly, depending on the zip code of your residence. 
  • We couldn’t find any clear information regarding a 100% satisfaction guarantee. But if you are not satisfied with a meal or receive some bad ingredients, the companies offer a support service that you can contact. They are very responsive and will promptly handle your issue.
  • Dinnerly goes the extra mile in terms of flexibility with their menu selection. Even though they have many different diet and lifestyle meals, their menu is open for al subscribers. 
  • In order for you to get started, both companies offer very attractive beginners promotions that you can see here (link to the promo pages?). Unfortunately, neither EveryPlate and Dinnerly offer a free trial.

EveryPlate vs Dinnerly website and ordering process

Registering and managing your subscription is super easy to do via the Dinnerly website. You can register, order your meals, change your meal selections, update your details, change payment methods and manage all the details of your account online. You can also access your past orders to keep track of the meals you have tried in addition to having a look at future menus. This includes recipes, list of ingredients and nutritional facts for every meal kit. To register, you just need to press the ‘sign up’ button and then follow the order process. This involves choosing your preferred plan, advising your location, selecting delivery times and paying. The final step is selecting what delicious meal kits you would like to try, and you can choose your meals up to four weeks in advance.

The registration and account management side of things for EveryPlate is also very user-friendly. The sign-up process is simple and straight forward. Once you have signed up, you can manage all elements of your account online. You can see past orders, pre-select menus, change your meals prior to delivery and update all the details of your account, including payment options. As an EveryPlate subscriber, you also have access to an online customer support person whenever required.

Dinnerly vs EveryPlate customer support

If you need any assistance with your subscription, you can easily contact both the EveryPlate and Dinnerly support team online chat, email or phone. Their support team, from our experience, is very responsive and will get back to you promptly. 

EveryPlate and Dinnerly delivery area

Both EveryPlate and Dinnerly are currently delivering their services to the vast majority of the continental USA. The delivery days and times depend on your location. In order to check their availability in your zone, enter your zip code during the checkout process. 

EveryPlate and Dinnerly – who is the winner?

We really loved our experience with both EveryPlate and Dinnerly. We honestly think they both offer an affordable meal kit service with incredible value for money. They genuinely are the cheapest meal kit companies in America that can suit even the smallest of budgets. Most importantly, at the end of the day – both companies offer delicious and very satisfying dinners!

While it is a close call, our favorite service between the two is EveryPlate. We found that their menu offers a pleasing amount of variety with a large number of tempting and interesting meals.  All the dishes we tried from their menu were delicious, satisfying and contained good-quality ingredients, despite their incredibly low prices.

EveryPlate IS OUR WINNER

  • Easy-to-cook meals
  • Best menu variety
  • Incredibly low prices.
  • What are the benefits of using Dinnerly and EveryPlate?

    Obviously, the biggest benefit of using Dinnerly and EveryPlate is the affordability of their services.

    With meal kits being available at $5 per serving, in many cases, we believe that using a meal kit service such as Dinnerly and EveryPlate will end up saving you money. When you consider how much time is spent on meal planning and then how much money you spend at the supermarket buying individual ingredients, in many cases a service such as Dinnerly and EveryPlate ends up being cheaper! Other benefits include the fact that by having all the grocery shopping, meal planning, and portion control done for you, you will be saving a significant amount of time. Meal kit services offer new menus to try every week so you will be enjoying a great deal of variety with a weekly changing menu. If you have any dietary requirements, you will find managing your lifestyle much easier with meals that fit with your diet while containing all the nutrients you need. Also, by receiving pre-portioned ingredients, you will be eliminating food waste which also saves you money. 

    Why use our Dinnerly vs EveryPlate comparison

    The meal-kit industry is one that has expanded rapidly over the last decade. There are now companies catering to every demographic, with menus that have been designed for almost every imaginable dietary and lifestyle requirement. There are so many companies out there making big promises about providing the best meal kits that it can be almost impossible knowing where to start.

    We created The Meal Kit Review to combat that sense of overwhelm and provide a place where people could go to find all the information they need about the meal kit industry and the individual companies in it.

    Our team at the Meal Kit Review are passionate about meal delivery services and have many years of experience using them personally. We are knowledgeable about all the advantages and disadvantages of meal kit companies and are able to assess companies with the eyes of seasoned professionals. We are proud of our review processes, our attention to detail and our experience, which allows us to present information that is relevant and gathered from first-hand tasting experience. We make sure that each company that is reviewed by The Meal Kit Review is tested personally by at least one of our team. This includes everything from subscribing to updating our account details, speaking to customer support, ordering meals, changing our orders, receiving deliveries and most importantly cooking and tasting the meal kits. This way we can let you know about all the details of each company which includes, (most importantly) how things actually taste!

    Close Menu

    Meal Kits December

    Sale